Connect with us

Baseball Writers

“Joe Talkin’ To Me?!” Western Fantasy Baseball Manifest Destiny: (Fantasy) All-Star Snubs


Not that it means anything in our fake game, but I enjoy taking stock in my fantasy roster at the All-Star break each season and seeing how many real life All-Stars I have been able to accumulate on my fake squad.  I won’t get any points in the standings, but it is a badge of honor, of sorts.

I like to see the differences between a true MLB All-Star and a waiver wire all-star.  In a lot of cases, the difference is a kooky MLB manager with an agenda picking the reality team.  In other cases, the sheer cost, or bargain, for a faux player is what makes them an All-Star.  I will not even bother addressing fan voting.

Keep this in mind: If your “All-Star” did not get the nod for the “mid summer classic”, don’t fret.  The All-Star break will serve as an actual break for your stars.  Your players will be nice and rested for a second half playoff push, in fantasy and reality.

Let’s take a peek at some of the first-half fantasy all-stars from the AL & NL West who were spurned by Ned Yost in the AL and Bruce Bochey in the NL.  For each snub, I will give you standard league fantasy rankings, MLFB Fantrax rankings, and suggestions of who they could have made the real life All-Star Team over.


Charlie Blackmon, OF, COL Fantrax Rank: 26th, Standard Rank: 24th

Blackmon was as big a surprise as there was last season, batting .288 with 82 R, 19 HR, 72 RBI, and 28 SB, ranking in fantasy’s top 20 off fantasy waiver wires.  He was labeled as a blackmon“fluke” by most, and went undrafted in many leagues.  He has come out this season hitting a nearly identical .286 and pacing 90+R, 20 HR, and 70+RBI.  He has proven that 2014 was no fluke.  The most impressive stat is the 23 SB he has already accumulated, putting him on pace for 40.  Bruce Bochy did not take notice, but fantasy owners sure have.  He will not be ignored during the 2016 draft season.  All-Star Replacement: Justin Upton


Chris Heston, SP, SF – Fantrax Rank:44th, Standard Rank: 186thHeston-667x300

Heston, a rookie, is a Fantrax special with his 0.48 HR/9, a stat standard leagues do not count.  He also has 9 W, 11 QS, and respectable rations of a 3.39 ERA and 1.20 WHIP.  Considering that he was picked up as a free agent early in the season, he is the definition of a waiver-wire all-star.  All-Star Replacement: Mark Melancon


Carson Smith, RP, SEA – Fatrax Rank: 52nd, Standard Rank: 126th

At 6’6, featuring a herky-jerky motion, and brandishing a 97 MPH fastball, who would not want to see him come out of the pen throwing gas against some of the NL’s best hitters?  Besides being fun as heck to watch, he has blown away 47 wannabe hitters in 36 IP.  He has issued a miserly 6 BB and opponents are hitting a paltry .169 versus him.  He is Seattle’s closer of the future, as soon as this summer, and for the waiver wire pickup he was, is a fantasy all-star.  All-Star Repalcement: Glen Perkins



Scott Kazmir, SP, OAK Fantrax Rank: 64th, Standard Rank: 93rd

Sure, he may be just a “back of the rotation guy” according to some, but he has a 2.49 ERA, 96 K in 100 IP, and opposing batters are hitting just .215 against him.  This is a pitcher who has lead the league in strikeouts and toed the rubber in the mid summer classic twice before.  He comes at a draft day bargain every year, thanks to his unwarranted reputation of being injury prone.  All-Star Replacement: Darren O’Day


Yovani Gallardo, SP, TEX – Fantrax Rank: 65th, Standard Rank: 129th

How in the heck is Gallardo posting a 2.62 ERA playing for Texas in his first season in the AL?  I’m not sure, but for a forgotten man on draft day, he is paying big rewards to owners brave enough to use him.  He has walked 40 batters, which is alarming.  Now might be the time to trade your fantasy all-star, before he becomes a fantasy dud.  All-Star Replacement: Glen Perkins


Huston Street, RP, LAA – Fantrax Rank: 80th, Standard Rank: 63rdstreet

Year in, year out, Street is one of the game’s dominant closers.  He usually spends a couple of weeks on the DL each season, and I think this hurts his draft stock.  He is a mid-to-late drafted closer every year, and I usually end up with him.  He has 24 saves already and has been dominant with a BAA of .181.  You are going to save a lot of games when you can’t be hit.  All-Star Replacement: Darren O’Day


Matt Duffy, 2B/3B/SS – Fantrax Rank: 213th, Standard Rank: 139th

Duffy is another waiver-wire gem (are you seeing a pattern for fantasy all-stars?) and is in the hunt for the NL ROY.  His best contribution is position versatility.  He is hitting .298 with 33 R and 41 RBI, but did not take over the Giants starting 3B job for good until the beginning of May. All-Star Replacement: DJ LeMahieu


Clayton Kershaw, SP, LAD – Fantrax Rank: 21st, Standard Rank: 34th

In what is being billed as a “bad year” for Kershaw, he has posted a 2.85 ERA with 160 K in 123 IP.  He is only 6-6, but has 15 QS.  Opponents are hitting a “Mets-Like” .217 against him.  Those numbers alone warrant an All-Star nod over most.  Now I know Kershaw has been “selected” to the team, but anytime the best pitcher in baseball is not SELECTED, something isn’t Kosher.  Could Bochy be putting the screws to the hated Dodgers?  If he is, it’s not a good look.  All-Star Replacement: Anybody but Max Scherzer


Bonus All-Star Video, Enjoy!

Remember to send questions to [twitter-follow screen_name=’theCiccone’] or to be featured in future columns.


(Click the BLUE link below to listen)

Major League Fantasy Sports Radio Show: Join Ej Garr and Corey D Roberts on Sunday July 19th from 7-9pm EST for this week’s episode of Major League Fantasy Sports Radio sponsored by the Sports Palooza Radio Network. Call in at 646-915-8596 to ask questions. This week’s topics will be Hits & Misses, and the players that will have a big second half.

Our guests this week include Professor Mark Rush, Joe Iannone, and Kyle Amore. Professor Rush is the Law Professor for Washington & Lee University in Lexington, VA as well as a writer for Ron Shandler’s JoeIannone is a writer with MLFS, and his articles focus on the AL East & AL Central divisions. You can catch his writings published every Monday. Kyle Amore is a former College ball player, and he is a writer with MLFS. Kyle handles everything fantasy related in the NL Central, and NL East divisions. Catch his articles published every Tuesday at 9am. Come join a spirited debate.
If you can’t make it to the live airing you can always download the podcast at I-Tunes or Google Play stores. Search for “Sports Palooza Radio Show”. Android owners download “Podcast Republic” and then search on podcast republic for “Sports Palooza Radio Show.”
(Click the BLUE link below to listen)
Major League Fantasy Football Weekly:  Join Lou Landers, Ron McCleese, and Jeff Nelson from 2-3:30pm on Saturday July 18th for this week’s episode of Major League Fantasy Football Weekly. Our guests this week are Matt Barkman, and Dennis Dunbar. Matt is a writer with, and he is focusing on the QB/TE positions. You can catch his articles published every Sunday morning. Dennis Dunbar is a member of, and a former colleague at MLFS. This week’s topics will be the QB, and TE positions. Feel free to leave a comment in the Q&A section during the show, and the guys will answer it during the show.
If you can’t catch the show live you can go to our YouTube channel and watch it when ever you want. Become a subscriber for instant email updates of shows after they post. Come by and ask some questions to the boys and have some fun!

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Help Support Our Growth!

Latest Podcast Episode

Radio Show Feed

MLFS Writers


Subscribe for Free

Help Support Our Growth!

More in Baseball Writers