/* */
Connect with us

Baseball Writers

“The Mad Professor” Returns: Studs and Duds — Summer Solstice Edition

Flag_of_Spain.svgHi sports fans.  I’m back from a hiatus in Spain and Portugal, where baseball is not even an afterthought.  Upon my return, the boss asked me to do a batting piece for a change and focus on expectations.  I can do this with no trouble since, in various leagues, I’m happily sitting on Carlos Gomez, Justin Upton and a couple of other folks whose shine has dulled more than a tad so far.

So, who are the duds and what are the criteria for handing these folks their sign?  While we are at it, who has exceeded expectations?  We could cover a lot of ground here. So, let’s keep that in mind perhaps for next week.  For now, let’s look at the stinkers.


Before ranting or declaring folks mostly dead, let’s keep in mind a couple of things.  First, it is seldom that the top 20 on draft day remain the top 20 throughout the season.  Each year, Ron Shandler discusses this in great detail in his Baseball Forecaster.

Statistics and Probability

This is great analysis, not only because it is robust in its scope, but also because it makes us aware of the fact that ballplayers are statistical animals.  As a result, we need to deal with the fact that a .280 hitter can have a .310 season or a .260 season, and still be a .280 hitter.  This is due to the natural, random variation that will occur in a player’s performance from year to year over a 162 game season.

If Mike Trout is a 40 HR hitter, we’ll be thrilled if he hits 48 and irritated if he hits only 32 this year.  But, both performances are equally probable and constitute part of the random, predictable variation in player performance.

So, keeping that in mind, we need to deal with the fact that, in some cases, our duds may simply be quality players who are operating at the lower end of their bell curves so far this year.  The question is how we distinguish between a bona fide dud and the player having a mediocre season, but still playing within his statistical bell curve?

Trying to generate meaningful measures

One real problem we have to contend with is the translation of performance variability into changes in either dollar values or player rankings.  A drop of 5 HR is a drop of 5 HR.  But how do we translate that into a comparable drop (or increase) in dollar value or ranking?

Mike TroutFor example, if Mike Trout drops from a preseason ranking of #1 to his current ranking, of #6, how do we compare that to other players’ performance?  Depending on how much you paid for him on draft day, a 5 point drop in rankings could prove disastrous.  Similarly, Trout’s dropping from 1 to 6 has a radically different importance than Joe Shlabotnik’s dropping from 250 to 255.

A real problem that rankings and dollar values present us with is their limits.  You can’t rank higher than #1.  Accordingly, the preseason #10 can rise 9 spots to number 1.  The preseason #100 can rise 50 spots — something the #10 player can’t do.  So, how do we compare a 50 point jump from #100 to a 9 point jump from #10?

Honestly, this is the stuff of some pretty heady math — much headier than the stuff of probability and statistics. So, let’s just look at some basics.  In this piece, I look at the top 225 batters based on their Yahoo! preseason rankings (This analysis draws upon data available as of 10 AM EDT on 19 June).

To avoid the problems I note above, let’s just look at tiers of players and see who, according to Yahoo!, has dropped the most. First, some summary numbers.

  • Of the top 225 batters, 130 have experienced drops in their rankings, 94 have experienced increases and one player, Josh Donaldson, has remained at his preseason rank (currently #5).
  • Of the top 25 players, only two, Josh Donaldson and Mookie Betts (preseason 19, current 7), have NOT experienced a drop in their ranking.

Mookie Betts






In some cases, the drop is due to suspension (Dee Gordon) or season ending injury (A.J. Pollock, Kyle Schwarber). I’ve kept such players in this analysis simply to acknowledge that the rankings drop can occur for any number of reasons.  But, as the graph below demonstrates, there has been a lot of underperformance in the league.

Scatterplot of change vs Pre-Season?


To a certain point, the graph is constrained.   The closer you are to the left hand  side, the higher was your original preseason ranking.  There is, for all intents and purposes, nowhere to go but down. Similarly, as you head to the right, the upside of ones game increases significantly because there is a finite number of active players in the major leagues.

Nonetheless, we do see that there are lots of folks in the middle of  the graph (preseason rank between 100 and 300), who saw their performance decline.


Batters GP* Pre-Season? Current change % Owned H/AB* R HR RBI SB AVG OPS
Mike Trout LAA – OF 68 1 6 -5 99% 75/248 47 14 47 9 0.302 0.949
Paul Goldschmidt Ari – 1B 69 2 14 -12 99% 71/245 39 14 45 9 0.29 0.943
Bryce Harper Was – OF 66 3 35 -32 99% 54/213 41 14 42 7 0.254 0.897
Josh Donaldson Tor – 3B 69 5 5 0 99% 72/259 60 17 46 5 0.278 0.961
Miguel Cabrera Det – 1B 68 6 40 -34 99% 81/261 39 14 41 0 0.31 0.921
Manny Machado Bal – 3B,SS 67 7 12 -5 99% 86/271 50 17 42 0 0.317 0.985
Nolan Arenado Col – 3B 66 8 9 -1 99% 74/255 48 20 57 1 0.29 0.956
Andrew McCutchen Pit – OF 65 9 202 -193 99% 64/262 38 10 27 2 0.244 0.74
Carlos Correa Hou – SS 65 10 129 -119 98% 64/250 30 9 33 8 0.256 0.776
Giancarlo Stanton Mia – OF 57 11 299 -288 98% 43/205 24 12 31 0 0.21 0.739
Kris Bryant ChC – 3B,OF 64 12 33 -21 99% 69/252 49 16 46 2 0.274 0.886
Anthony Rizzo ChC – 1B 65 13 30 -17 99% 61/231 41 16 50 2 0.264 0.939
José Altuve Hou – 2B 69 14 2 12 99% 92/270 47 10 38 18 0.341 0.959
José Bautista Tor – OF 65 16 107 -91 99% 54/235 41 12 41 1 0.23 0.815
Edwin Encarnación Tor – 1B 70 17 24 -7 98% 69/264 41 18 61 2 0.261 0.878
José Abreu CWS – 1B 67 18 159 -141 97% 70/263 28 10 41 0 0.266 0.762
Mookie Betts Bos – OF 67 19 7 12 99% 85/293 60 14 49 11 0.29 0.853
Dee Gordon Mia – 2B 21 20 709 -689 58% 25/94 13 0 5 6 0.266 0.629
Buster Posey SF – C,1B 60 21 120 -99 99% 62/222 36 8 31 4 0.279 0.799
A.J. Pollock Ari – OF 22 1087 -1065 61% -/-
Joey Votto Cin – 1B 69 23 94 -71 97% 59/239 39 11 36 5 0.247 0.81
Charlie Blackmon Col – OF 54 26 102 -76 96% 61/211 36 7 30 6 0.289 0.817
George Springer Hou – OF 69 27 53 -26 98% 76/284 45 15 41 4 0.268 0.826
Chris Davis Bal – 1B,OF 66 31 90 -59 98% 52/236 48 16 40 0 0.22 0.81
J.D. Martínez Det – OF 65 32 70 -38 94% 72/252 36 12 39 1 0.286 0.878


In the top 25, the biggest duds to date are Giancarlo Stanton (-288), Andrew McCutchen (-193), Jose Abreu (-144) and Carlos Correa (-119). Stanton’s drop should not come as a complete surprise.  He’s returning from a frightening injury in which he took a baseball to the face.

Carlos CorreaCorrea’s an outstanding talent, but he just got here; he does not yet have 750 plate appearances.  His walk rate has improved, but his K% has increased as well.  His BABIP is up 30 points from last year’s .296.  BA is down 25 points, OBP is up 7, but SLG is down 90 points from last years’ .424.  9 HR, 33 RBI and 8 SB from the SS position after 250 AB is nothing to sniff at.  Seems his biggest problem is that the pundits’ expectations were much too high and many of us took the bait.  If any owners are frustrated, do make an offer.

Abreu is suffering similar problems of perceptions and expectations.  He has established himself as a 30-100-.300 player.  In 295 PA so far, his line is 10-41-.266.  If we project that over the roughly 640 PA he has averaged in his career, it works out to 22 HR and 89 RBI for the season. He’s hitting well below his career .300 BA, so he is a buy low candidate.

What’s important to keep in mind with someone like Abreu is, as we know from Bull Durham, the difference between a .250 hitter and a .300 hitter is a hit a week.  So, before we declare him a bust, take note that the so-called bust is a difference of 4 hits a month so far.  He’s suffering, in no small part, because his BABIP is down to .297 (the last two years, he was at .333 and .356, respectively).  Trade with confidence.

McCutchenMcCutcheon is in a similar situation.  His BABIP this year is below .300.  Normally, his BABIP is .340 or better.  His slash line is 10-27-.244 after 293 PA.  His LD and FB percentages are up, but his hard hit percentage is down.  While he’s stolen only 2 bases so far this season, it’s important to note that his SB count has dropped steadily over the last 5 years.


In general, then, these tarnished stars are in funks.  But they are well within their statistical spreads, and are worth talking to your league owners about over 4th of July ales.  Their careers all indicate that they are solid buys.


The Biggest Losers

Batters GP* Pre-Season? Current change % Owned H/AB* R HR RBI SB AVG OPS
A.J. Pollock Ari – OF 22 1087 -1065 61% -/-
Kyle Schwarber ChC – C,OF 2 53 991 -938 27% 0/4 0 0 0 0 0 0.2
Mark Teixeira NYY – 1B 48 175 1041 -866 30% 30/167 16 3 12 1 0.18 0.534
Travis d’Arnaud NYM – C 13 176 1024 -848 45% “9/46 3 0 1 0 0.196 0.549
Prince Fielder Tex – 1B 66 54 881 -827 77% 49/245 18 5 34 0 0.2 0.579
Devin Mesoraco Cin – C 16 241 1059 -818 14% “7/50 2 0 1 0 0.14 0.378
Michael Brantley Cle – OF 11 77 887 -810 74% “9/39 5 0 7 1 0.231 0.561
Erick Aybar Atl – SS 50 279 1062 -783 5% 34/167 9 0 10 2 0.204 0.503
Kolten Wong StL – 2B 50 131 899 -768 30% 29/130 14 1 6 3 0.223 0.589
Carlos Gómez Hou – OF 48 49 806 -757 70% 36/172 15 3 12 8 0.209 0.587
Pablo Sandoval Bos – 3B 3 261 1007 -746 12% 0/6 0 0 0 0 0 0.143
Byron Buxton Min – OF 35 230 940 -710 28% 21/108 11 1 7 4 0.194 0.571
Yan Gomes Cle – C 52 216 921 -705 46% 31/184 17 7 28 0 0.168 0.546
Ben Revere Was – OF 37 104 799 -695 52% 32/150 19 1 12 7 0.213 0.544
Dee Gordon Mia – 2B ? 21 20 709 -689 58% 25/94 13 0 5 6 0.266 0.629


Ignoring Pollock, Schwarber, Brantly (DL) and Gordon, we see that the biggest disappointments in terms of expectations have been Fielder and Carlos Gomez.  They were top 100 (not top 25) players to start the season.  But each has underperformed radically.

Fielder’s counting stats are not that far off from his career numbers.  But it’s important to note that his GB% has increased, and LD% has decreased steadily the last several years. His career hard hit% is 36.2, but in his last 3 years, he has been closer to 30 than to 36.  Since 2010, his walk rate has declined steadily.  It has been in the single digits both last year and this year.  His K% is at his career average of 16.7, but his BABIP of .221 is way below his career mark of .301.  The key here is that Fielder’s value derived from his power.  His OPS has decreased steadily since 2009.  He’s had ups and downs, but never threatened that 1.017 mark again.  While we can expect some improvement in the second half based on his BABIP, that is more likely to translate into OBP than power.  This is an aging star, who no longer offers the power that made him such valuable fantasy commodity.

Gomez has been on and off of the DL, but his season has been a terrible disappointment.  His LD% is down and his GB% is up.  His contact rate is down.  He was injured last year.  But pundits said he still owned the skills and projected him as a solid buy with a strong upside.  The Mets backed out of a trade for him over the winter because of concerns about his hip. Perhaps he is hiding an injury.  Regardless, his performance has been lackluster at best.  The good news for owners is that Gomez has seemingly begun to turn things around in June.  Over the last 2 weeks, he has shown a line of 3-7-.300 with 2 SB in 40 plate appearances.  His superstar caliber speed is clearly a thing of the past.  But, if he can right his ship, he still offers five category value.

With the exception of Fielder, these struggling players all offer good second half value.  Their performances have been below their career averages.  But in some cases, I think it’s clear that they are the victims of unrealistic expectations.  The All-Star break is just a couple of weeks away. We are only halfway through the season.  I suspect that we’ll see significant recovery for most of the players we’ve touched upon in this article.  Make some offers.  They will pay dividends.

In closing, again, keep in mind that the translation of real stats into dollar values or relative rankings is a peculiar task.  It’s extraordinarily difficult to convert an entire hitting or pitching portfolio into one accurate and meaningful number that amounts, essentially, to an index that you can use to compare players.  Stay tuned.


(Click the RED link below to listen)

Major League Fantasy Baseball Weekly: Join Lou Landers and Kyle Amore live on Thursday June 23rd, 2016 from 8-10pm EST for episode #19 of Major League Fantasy Baseball Weekly. This will run every Thursday as a live broadcast that will take live callers at 323-870-4395. Press 1 to speak with the host. This week we will be the first of 2 episodes covering the MLB Draft. This week we will cover the American League side of the draft.

Our guest this week is Bryan Luhrs. Bryan is the owner of Real Deal Dynasty Sports, and a writer with majorleaguefantasysports.com.


(Click the RED link below to listen)

Major League Fantasy Football Weekly: Join Lou LandersZak Sauer, and Coach Jeff Nelson live Saturday June 25th, 2016 from 1-2:30pm EST for episode #24 of Major League Fantasy Football Weekly. We will run our show on Saturday until August 27th, and then move back to Tuesday nights from 8-10pm EST on September 13th. This is a live broadcast and we do take callers at 323-870-4395. We will discuss the AFC West  from a NFL and fantasy football perspective.

You can find our shows on I-Tunes. Just search for Major League Fantasy Sports in the podcasts section. For Android users go to “Podcast Republic,” then download that app, and search for “Major League Fantasy Sports Show”

Unrepentant Red Sox fan and all things Boston. Deflategate was a joke. Boston Latin School is awesome. Harvard and Johns Hopkins alma maters... Besides that... Stanley D. and Nikki Waxberg Professor of Politics and Law at Washington and Lee University. Wrote for Ron Shandler's Shandler Park for two summers and have been on board with MLFS since 2011. Been at Washington and Lee since 1990 with a brief hiatus (2010-2013) in the Middle East. Currently developing that last word in Fantasy Baseball analysis. Married to Flor, Dad to William and Alex, and adopted daughter Reem. Soon to be father and law to Meaghann. Alpha male to the world's super-pup, Humphrey. Life is not bad.



  1. Pingback: Mid-Season Baseball Analysis 2016 « Mark Rush

  2. Pingback: Moonlighting: Reflections on 2016 Baseball Analysis « Mark Rush

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Help Support Our Growth!

Major League Fantasy Baseball Show Episode #167, 6/23/2019 Host Brian Roach, Jr., Co-Host Cole Freel, Guest Kevin Bzdek

Major League Fantasy Baseball Show Episode #169, 8/4/2019 Host Cole Freel, Guest Joe Iannone

Radio Show Feed

Blog Authors

avatar for Ben WardiBen Wardi

I am a recent college graduate from a small liberal arts school in Atlanta, GA. I'm a sports junkie and a diehard Atlanta sports fan.

avatar for Brandon ZimanBrandon Ziman

Grew up playing baseball since I could hold a bat. Played baseball through high school and college. Somehow became a Yankee fan even though I ...

avatar for Brian Roach, JrBrian Roach, Jr

Baseball fan through and through. Follows every team, every player and every transaction. Graduated Lasell College in 2013. Covers high sc...

avatar for Bryan LuhrsBryan Luhrs

Faith, Family and Fantasy Sports.These are the three words that best describe me. I am a faithful husband and father of 6 amazing children. I ...

avatar for Cole FreelCole Freel

Bachelors in English and History from Indiana University. Borderline-Obsessed Fantasy Baseball Writer who also dabbles in Football, Basketball...

avatar for Corey D RobertsCorey D Roberts

Owner and creator of Major League Fantasy Sports. We will provide you with the best tools to be successful in your leagues no matter if ...

avatar for Geordie EasterbrookGeordie Easterbrook

I’m a former pitcher from upstate New York, and a proud Demon Deacon. Go Deacs! I’ve been playing fantasy football and baseball for the be...

avatar for James WilkJames Wilk

I grew up a Dallas Cowboy's fan in Washington Redskins' country, but I currently reside in Florida. I have played fantasy sports since 1999,...

avatar for Joe IannoneJoe Iannone

I'm an accountant and an amateur writer of fiction and sports commentary, mostly baseball. I've been a student of the game of baseball since...

avatar for Kevin BzdekKevin Bzdek

I've been playing fantasy baseball for 14 years. I am also an auditor and CPA, where I analyze information on a daily basis. Combined, my pas...

avatar for Kyle AmoreKyle Amore

I'm a former collegiate and semi-pro baseball player. I underwent successful Tommy John Surgery in 2008, and can give a wide-range of tips on...

avatar for Mark RushMark Rush

Unrepentant Red Sox fan and all things Boston. Deflategate was a joke. Boston Latin School is awesome. Harvard and Johns Hopkins alma mater...

avatar for Matt BarkmanMatt Barkman

A/S/L...like the old school AOL instant messenger days...
Elementary Physical Education by day, chasing around my 1 and 2 year old boy...

avatar for Mike RiggallMike Riggall

I've been coaching lacrosse since 2002 and playing fantasy football since 2006. I've racked up several championships over the years includi...

avatar for Nick GehlbachNick Gehlbach

Husband and father of three. Have a love of all things baseball. When not burying myself in baseball (especially fantasy) I enjoy fish...

avatar for Todd NevinTodd Nevin

A business analyst by day, pursuing all things baseball by night. My favorite day of the year is opening day and my favorite sound is the crac...

Help Support Our Growth!

More in Baseball Writers